Liberty Park Press

Liberty Park Press

  • Headlines
  • Politics
  • http://libertyparkpress.com/very-cheap-cialis/
  • http://libertyparkpress.com/buy-levitra-online-australia/
  • http://libertyparkpress.com/buy-levitra-online-no-prescription/
  • viagra rxlist
  • Sports

Order in the Court: Are Governors Over-Stepping Their Authority?

May 19, 2020 By Dave Workman

Oregon Gov. Kate Brown is one of several governors whose emergency orders are being challenged in court. (Screen snip, YouTube, KGW)

Fox News is reporting on the latest legal activities against primarily Democrat governors and their emergency orders aimed ostensibly at reducing the spread of the coronavirus, raising a question about whether these state chief executives have overstepped their authority.

In Wisconsin, Democrat Gov. Tony Evers was slapped down by that state’s Supreme Court, which nullified his “safer at home” order “on the grounds that his administration did not have the power to unilaterally impose the restrictions without the input of the state legislature.”

In Oregon Monday, a county circuit court judge handed Democrat Gov. Kate Brown a setback by declaring her emergency order extension “null and void” but the decision was blocked hours later by that state’s Supreme Court. The Oregon high court issued a stay, pending full review of the case.

Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker, sued in federal court by the Second Amendment Foundation, Firearms Policy Coalition and Commonwealth Second Amendment, Inc., issued a “reopening plan” that includes firearm retailers and gun ranges on a list of businesses that can operate, with certain restrictions.

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has been under fire for weeks, leading to demonstrations at the Capitol in Lansing. She is being sued by Republican state lawmakers challenging her extension of an emergency order that locked down the state weeks ago.

The list, as detailed by Fox News, goes on, and the governors involved have almost uniformly argued what they’ve done is necessary to stem the spread of the COVID-19 pandemic. One Republican, Gov. Mike DeWine of Ohio, has also been sued by gym operators, the Fox story said.

“It’s insulting,” argued Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker. “It’s dangerous and people’s safety and health have now been put at risk.”

But is something being lost in perspective, or deliberately deflected? The question among grassroots activists fighting back against shutdowns and demanding their states re-open isn’t whether the coronavirus isn’t serious and people are getting sick. The question is whether the governors can actually legally do what they’ve done.

Oregon’s Brown, according to the lower court ruling, extended her order beyond a 30-day limit without involvement of the Legislature.

Governors who ordered gun shops closed, or left them off arbitrary lists of “essential” businesses, have been challenged on Second Amendment grounds. When an official includes a marijuana shop to remain open but closes a gun store, activists have argued this isn’t about keeping people healthy, but about using a crisis to impose their gun control agenda.

Fox News senior judicial analyst, former New Jersey Judge Andrew Napolitano, contends the Garden State’s “stay at home” order is unconstitutional.

“We need more people to resist these unlawful incursions into freedom by the governors,” Napolitano said during an appearance on the “Fox and Friends” morning program.

It doesn’t help clarify the situation when there is disagreement about COVID-19 data. Just enter “COVID-19 deaths overstated” on a favorite search engine and one gets differing opinions with headlines such as “Colorado amends coronavirus death count – says fewer have died of COVID-19 than previously reported,” along with a report at Business Insider that contends, “Comparisons of the number of deaths from the coronavirus and the seasonal flu likely undercount the former and overcount the latter, according to a new report from two doctors.”

Forbes published an analysis of the dispute last week, which may answer lots of questions but raise new ones.

Still, this does not answer the original question; whether state governors have overstepped their authority by shutting down their states, and essentially closing down the economy.

What might be argued is that state governors, more than the federal government and the Trump administration, are far more responsible for the crashed economy and skyrocketing spike in unemployment in March and April.

That’s why the lawsuits challenging emergency orders are important. They could place limits on gubernatorial authority, or at least provide road maps for state lawmakers on where the lines should be drawn.

Facebook Comments

Related

Filed Under: 2nd Amendment, Headlines, Politics Tagged With: Gretchen Whitmer, J.B. Pritzker, Kate Brown, SAF, Shutdown orders, Tony Evers

About Dave Workman

Dave Workman is an award-winning career journalist with an expertise in firearms and the outdoors. He is the author of several books dealing with firearms politics. He has a degree in editorial journalism from the University of Washington and is a lifelong Washington resident.

Please Subscribe

We respect your email privacy

Powered by AWeber Email Marketing

 

Featured Stories

House Republicans Targeting Biden Admin’s Pistol Brace Rule

N.C. Bill to End Pistol Purchase Permits Heads to Governor

MI Senate Democrats Pass 11 Gun Control Bills in Thursday Vote

COMMENTARY: Joe Biden is coming for your Glock 7!

2A Advocates Blast Biden’s Exec. Order on Gun Control

German Authorities Considering New Gun Restrictions After Hamburg

Bristling Reactions to Biden’s Executive Order on Guns

DC Project Suicide Prevention Educator Wins $1 Million Grant

VIRAL STORIES

Don’t Look Now, But The Clock Is Ticking

Domino Bot Wows Internet

The Soviet Ghost Town Of The Arctic Expanse

These Insects Redefine “The Groove”

Colossal Pizza Slice Marks The End Of An Era

The Hardheaded And Plummeting Ratings Of Sports Television

Escaping The Madness- Where On Earth Does One Go To Avoid Bubonic Politicization?

Driving A Jet Engine Or Racing A Car? Choose Wisely

About Us

Liberty Park Press is an online information website dedicated to providing you with breaking, useful, or interesting information.

Read More

PRIVACY AND TERMS

Welcome to Libertyparkpress.com. If you continue to browse and use this website you are agreeing to comply with and be bound by the following terms and conditions of use:
Continue Reading…

CONTACT US

Liberty Park Press
12500 NE 10th Place
Bellevue, WA 98005

Copyright © 2023 · Liberty Park Press Inc · all rights reserved · Log in