Liberty Park Press

Liberty Park Press

  • Headlines
  • Politics
  • what are the benefits of dating a married man
  • dating sites in carletonville
  • christian speed dating toronto
  • Money
  • Sports

Huge Victory for 2A as 9th Circuit Panel Smacks CA Magazine Ban

August 14, 2020 By Dave Workman

A 2-1 ruling in the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco holds that California’s ban on such magazines is unconstitutional.

The California Rifle & Pistol Association scored a major victory for gun rights Friday when a Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals panel ruled 2-1 that California’s ban on so-called “large capacity magazines” violates the Second Amendment.

The case, known as Duncan v. Becerra, was brought on behalf of several individual citizens including Virginia Duncan—for whom the case is named—Richard Lewis, Patrick Lovette, David Marguglio and Christopher Waddell. The ruling may be read here. Plaintiffs were represented by attorney Chuck Michel.

Friday’s majority opinion, written by Circuit Judge Kenneth K. Lee, upheld an earlier decision by District Judge Roger T. Benitez in U.S. District Court in the Southern District of California.

It is not clear whether the state will ask for an en banc hearing before a full Ninth Circuit panel, or appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

NRA spokeswoman Amy Hunter issued a statement: “This is a huge win for the NRA and gun owners nationwide. The 9th Circuit, which isn’t often a favorable court for gun owners, ruled it is unconstitutional to place arbitrary bans on magazines that hold more than 10 rounds. The judge who authored the opinion in this case was appointed by President Trump. That means everyone who voted pro-gun in 2016 played a role in this significant win. It’s a reminder to everyone: Vote in November. Your rights depend on it.”

“Firearm magazines are ‘arms’ under the Second Amendment.”—Judge Kenneth K. Lee

Judge Lee was joined by Circuit Judge Consuelo M. Callahan in his majority opinion. District Judge Barbara M.G. Lynn, visiting from Texas and sitting by designation, dissented.

Gun rights advocates are calling attention to the fact that the court majority applied strict scrutiny in its analysis of the case and the law being challenged.

“Applying this court’s precedent,” Judge Lee explained, “we hold that strict scrutiny is the proper standard of constitutional review. California Penal Code section 32310 cannot withstand this level of scrutiny and is unconstitutional.”

The judge noted a few paragraphs later, “Firearm magazines are ‘arms’ under the Second Amendment. Magazines enjoy Second Amendment protection for a simple reason: Without a magazine, many weapons would be useless, including ‘quintessential’ self-defense weapons like the handgun.”

This concurs with an opinion issued in the Third Circuit, in a case challenging a New Jersey regulation, the ruling noted.

Judge Lee went on to explain why large capacity magazines are not “unusual arms.”

Citing the 2008 Supreme Court ruling in District of Columbia v. Heller, Judge Lee detailed, “In addressing ‘unusualness,’ the Supreme Court held that ‘the Second Amendment extends, prima facie, to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding.” In other words, just because a weapon was not in existence during the founding era does not mean it is ‘unusual.’”

As if to underscore the phrase “elections matter,” it should be noted that Judge Lee is a Donald Trump appointee and Judge Callahan was appointed by George W. Bush. Judge Lynn is a Bill Clinton appointee, according to biographies on all three found online.

In hailing the ruling, Alan Gottlieb, founder and executive vice president of the Second Amendment Foundation, which has a similar case pending in California, issued a statement: “While this was not our case, this is a victory for all gun owners, and the majority opinion reflects our arguments in (the) amicus brief we submitted.”

Judge Lee’s opinion is being considered “huge” because it upholds the lower court, and because it came out of the Ninth Circuit. It also solidifies the opinion that magazines are protected by the Second Amendment.

Facebook Comments

Filed Under: 2nd Amendment, Headlines, Politics Tagged With: California, Elections, Federal court, Magazine ban

About Dave Workman

Dave Workman is an award-winning career journalist with an expertise in firearms and the outdoors. He is the author of several books dealing with firearms politics. He has a degree in editorial journalism from the University of Washington and is a lifelong Washington resident.

Please Subscribe

We respect your email privacy

Powered by AWeber Email Marketing

 

Featured Stories

ATF Issuing Suppressors for the ‘Health and Safety’ of its Agents, but What About Us?

WA Supreme Court Upholds Ban on ‘Large-Capacity Magazines’

Missouri Again Tries 2A Preservation Act; Earlier Law Struck Down

Minneapolis Murder Suspect Has Criminal Past; Will MN Consider More Gun Laws?

Applause, Angst Follow Removal of ‘Gun Violence’ Victims’ Images at ATF

The ‘First 100’ – How A Course Correction Pleased Gun Owners, Riled Antis

Bondi Poll: Conservatives Like Her, Liberals Not So Much

Stunning Sea Change: DOJ Files SCOTUS Amicus Fully Backing 2A

VIRAL STORIES

Don’t Look Now, But The Clock Is Ticking

Domino Bot Wows Internet

The Soviet Ghost Town Of The Arctic Expanse

These Insects Redefine “The Groove”

Colossal Pizza Slice Marks The End Of An Era

The Hardheaded And Plummeting Ratings Of Sports Television

Escaping The Madness- Where On Earth Does One Go To Avoid Bubonic Politicization?

Driving A Jet Engine Or Racing A Car? Choose Wisely

About Us

Liberty Park Press is an online information website dedicated to providing you with breaking, useful, or interesting information.

Read More

PRIVACY AND TERMS

Welcome to Libertyparkpress.com. If you continue to browse and use this website you are agreeing to comply with and be bound by the following terms and conditions of use:
Continue Reading…

CONTACT US

Liberty Park Press
12500 NE 10th Place
Bellevue, WA 98005

Copyright © 2025 · Liberty Park Press Inc · all rights reserved · Log in